So we have seen the Island being moved and moving in time..
I wonder if when the Island was moved in the past (am I'm sure it was).. maybe where the Island "popped" up, was where the black rock was. Would explain how the ship ended up in the middle of the island..
Or.. it was just a really big wave.. lol

I agree the island was moved, but i dont think it's moving along with the lefties as they pop on and out of time. I think the island went one place and the lefties went another.

Richard's Comment "I didnt go anywhere John, you went"

Or the island didn't really move, it was Ben summing it up for john in a way he knew john would understand. If he had said "i'm going to move the spacetime coordinates for the mouth of the wormhole that connects the real world to the island" John probably would have punched Ben in the face.

I dont believe it has moved in the past, richard seemed baffled when locke said he was from the future.

Or the island didn't really move, it was Ben summing it up for john in a way he knew john would understand. If he had said "i'm going to move the spacetime coordinates for the mouth of the wormhole that connects the real world to the island" John probably would have punched Ben in the face.

Ben didn't say anything to Locke about moving the island. Jacob said that to Locke and Locke repeated it to Ben and Hurley.

The island moved...we saw it disappear. So its irreverant to be saying the island didn't move...of course it did. Move = TT in this case. Is it moving to diffrent parts of the Ocean. Don't know, don't care.