I thinks it is worth re-watching it..YouTube- Lost.04.Mobisode.13*

Was it the 'real' Christian Shepard (as seen in the finale) or MIB?
In any case I guess that now, in the light of the finale, even this small 'missing piece' gives coherence to the whole series

So are we supposed to believe that white shoes Christian is the actual Christian and black shoes Christian is Smokey?

I don't know if that makes sense. Did he have white shoes on when we first saw him?

I think we're supposed to believe that all on-island instances of Christian are really Smokey.

As for freighter Christian and hospital lobby Christian -- :confused:.

If it's Smokey, why would he call him his son?

In any case I guess that now, in the light of the finale, even this small 'missing piece' gives coherence to the whole series
Whuh? On the contrary. If anything, it shows the writers had no idea where they were going, really...


If it's Smokey, why would he call him his son?
And if Smokey was Jacob's brother, why did he call him "my friend" in the season 5 finale?
Same answer: the writers didn't know where they were going with all that. And they screwed up.

http://gallery.lost-media.com/displayimage.php?pid=16196&fullsize=1 yes Christian Shephard had on the white shoes

"go and wake him up"

cut to Jack waking up on his own, and then the doggy alarm call arriving. hmmm



another possibility, Hurely can see dead people, maybe dogs can too?