iwonder
01-06-2005, 11:01 AM
ok, we all know there's a number on the plane's wing 5025 and it does appear that the envie with the plane is the same single envie in the safety deposit box from it's shape/size/coloring
Now I'm guessing the envelope still contained everything she got from the box, even if it means there's something else in the envie beyond the plane... if not the number on the wing could be the entire reason for the robbery.
I think there's a few possible reasons why she was acting so suspicious about getting the case back... either for other info that's still in the envie she has or she expected more to be in the case, such as a case file against her, so with that not being there she'd be awfully relieved that the info won't come out on the island... but it could still be around.
now as to the marshall.... We know he supposedly believed a story Kate fed him and felt betrayed by her based on his lines to her in the plane. At first I thought it was because she came off as an innocent victim and eventually he found out she was a key player in the robbery/crime. But what about if he was in on something with her and she ran whether he believes:
she conned him and the plane is worthless when it isn't there was supposed to be more in the safe deposit box and she ran when there wasn't so her secret accomplices wouldn't get her for coming back with nothing because that envie with the plane is worth everything and she took off with it
Any of those could be a reason for why he despised her so much and distrusts her. Not finding a case file could confirm for her that he really was the bad guy she believed and that he wasn't taking her into custody, so no guilt over his death, etc.
I doubt she was after the case to keep anything of value, more to hide her secrets... obviously Sawyer and others didn't know of her being a criminal of some kind... only Hurley and Jack saw her mug shot, so it's understandable that if she wanted the plane and/or documents within the case that she'd not want anyone else knowing she had things in it... but the only reason to keep trying to hide it from Jack, imho would be cause she expected more info in there. Why else hide the key she lifted from the wallet? If she'd just shown it to him righth away when they dug up the marshall then he'd have built back a little trust/not lost so much. And if all she took was an envie with a toy plane he'd have been curious but not so suspicious since she provided the most trustworthy survivor to give the guns to.
Now I'm guessing the envelope still contained everything she got from the box, even if it means there's something else in the envie beyond the plane... if not the number on the wing could be the entire reason for the robbery.
I think there's a few possible reasons why she was acting so suspicious about getting the case back... either for other info that's still in the envie she has or she expected more to be in the case, such as a case file against her, so with that not being there she'd be awfully relieved that the info won't come out on the island... but it could still be around.
now as to the marshall.... We know he supposedly believed a story Kate fed him and felt betrayed by her based on his lines to her in the plane. At first I thought it was because she came off as an innocent victim and eventually he found out she was a key player in the robbery/crime. But what about if he was in on something with her and she ran whether he believes:
she conned him and the plane is worthless when it isn't there was supposed to be more in the safe deposit box and she ran when there wasn't so her secret accomplices wouldn't get her for coming back with nothing because that envie with the plane is worth everything and she took off with it
Any of those could be a reason for why he despised her so much and distrusts her. Not finding a case file could confirm for her that he really was the bad guy she believed and that he wasn't taking her into custody, so no guilt over his death, etc.
I doubt she was after the case to keep anything of value, more to hide her secrets... obviously Sawyer and others didn't know of her being a criminal of some kind... only Hurley and Jack saw her mug shot, so it's understandable that if she wanted the plane and/or documents within the case that she'd not want anyone else knowing she had things in it... but the only reason to keep trying to hide it from Jack, imho would be cause she expected more info in there. Why else hide the key she lifted from the wallet? If she'd just shown it to him righth away when they dug up the marshall then he'd have built back a little trust/not lost so much. And if all she took was an envie with a toy plane he'd have been curious but not so suspicious since she provided the most trustworthy survivor to give the guns to.