A buddy was trying to persusade me into thinking that Nathan was an Other but not from the same group as Goodwin. My question is...is there any proof that Nathan WAS on the plane?

Nathan was not an Other, he was a red herring according to TPTB.

Yeah... I thought they made it pretty obvious that Goodwin convinced Ana Lucia to turn on Nathan so they would have someone to blame.

I definitely don't think that he is a real crash survivor. I mean hot air balloon? Can you that be anymore weird or random? Probably not. Well, i think that he is one of the others, but have no clue which group. I guess we'll jut have to wait and find out!!! :biggrin:

Hold on, I must have missed something here...

Which episode do we actually get to see this 'Nathan'? I may have missed that part of something.

And considering Henry Gale came from a 'Hot Air Balloon' (or did he?),

And EarlhamGirl stated that Nathan said something about this, I can't help thinking that they're connected to each other. Which is true, and which is false?

I'm guessing what I just said doesn't make any sense at all. :\

Nathan was not an Other, he just had some embarrasing bowel problems.

Nathan was not an Other, he just had some embarrasing bowel problems. canadian too! (just kiddin canadian lagers...!)

i dont recall nathan saying anything about a balloon

My question is: Why did Goodwin think Nathan was evil?

My question is: Why did Goodwin think Nathan was evil?

He didnt, he was just trying to divert attention from himself.

I definitely don't think that he is a real crash survivor. I mean hot air balloon? Can you that be anymore weird or random? Probably not. Well, i think that he is one of the others, but have no clue which group. I guess we'll jut have to wait and find out!!! :biggrin:


Um, are you talking about Nathan (guy Ana-Lucia threw in the pit, later killed by Goodwin), or Henry Gale (guy Danielle trapped in a net, currenrtly a prisoner in Swan station)?

I suppose. Yeah, thanks.

Wait, wait, wait...

I didn't see any scenes with 'Nathan' or anything similar to what is being posted...

Are those deleted scenes? I've watched all the episodes everyone else has but yet I've seen nothing to understand what you're talking about...

Any specific episode to which this happens? I think it was probably from that 'Episode 25' (the one which was kind of like an island review) which was not an actual episode...I didn't see episode 25, though. Is that where you got it from?

EDIT: Forget this post, I just realised I downloaded Season 1 Episode 7, and not Season 2 Episode 7!!! How could I have been so stupid! :(

Oh, and I understand what you're talking about now. I've just seen The Other 48 Days. :)