Hatgirl
01-19-2005, 07:54 PM
Hi Javi!
Could you clear up a little question for a few of us? How many fuselage survivors are there now? Are there 45 or 46?
We have debated this to death and need your help! Both sides are using the same dialogue as proof :D
From "Raised by Another", when Hurley tells Jack & Co. about Ethan:
* * *HURLEY: The manifest. Jack, the census -- the names of everyone who survived.
* * *Jack: All forty-six of us.
* * *HURLEY: I interviewed everyone --here, at the beach. I got their names. One of them isn't in the manifest. He wasn't on the plane.
So does Hurley mean there were 46 people on his census but only 45 on the manifest, or does he mean there were 47 people on his census but 46 only on the manifest?
Us, obsessive? Nah....
Hatgirl
Could you clear up a little question for a few of us? How many fuselage survivors are there now? Are there 45 or 46?
We have debated this to death and need your help! Both sides are using the same dialogue as proof :D
From "Raised by Another", when Hurley tells Jack & Co. about Ethan:
* * *HURLEY: The manifest. Jack, the census -- the names of everyone who survived.
* * *Jack: All forty-six of us.
* * *HURLEY: I interviewed everyone --here, at the beach. I got their names. One of them isn't in the manifest. He wasn't on the plane.
So does Hurley mean there were 46 people on his census but only 45 on the manifest, or does he mean there were 47 people on his census but 46 only on the manifest?
Us, obsessive? Nah....
Hatgirl