libby is not real. think about it. she has been in alot of scenes with alot of people but do any of them talk to her. I cant remember her talking to anyone but hurley. even way back when hurley asked sawyer if he thought she was hot...did sawyer even know who he was refering to. i just came up with this thought and i really dont remember her talking. kinda like dave.

You can't be for real.

what about all the interaction with Sawyer and Michael and Ana in The Other 48 Days??

Libby talked to Claire... and got her to remember her flash backs!

Ummm the guys leg that she snapped back into place back on the tallies original landing spot sure seemed like he felt she was real. :)

We watched her talk to Ana Lucia etc, during the first 48 days. We watched her talk to Claire to bring back her memories.

She talked with Anna. Crazy woman are hot.

She talked to Jack before the card game...remember the Neosporin?:):)

You can't be for real.

no doubt. This place makes me want to cry sometimes.

I think my IQ may have dropped reading this thread

Jesus, yes she is real she is being played by an actor named Cythia Watros. Man people, not everything is trickery. Some things are, but not all things?

This place is really painful sometimes.. Its one thing to try to put the puzzle pieces together, but its quite another thing to make up puzzle pieces and force them to fit. It seems now that some of us are willing to call bs on some of the crazier things.

I think my IQ may have dropped reading this thread
haha....my husband ACTUALLY asked me the same thing about Libby. I about smacked him.....Now, can we think of anyone on the island that may not be real????.....hmmm.....get your thinking caps on.

Lost1963, i do feel sorry for you having everyone having a go at you but come on, you must have some prety big distractions when watching LOST if you have never seen Libby interact with anyone.
Now lets let this thread RIP

Shamu x

libby is not real. think about it. she has been in alot of scenes with alot of people but do any of them talk to her. I cant remember her talking to anyone but hurley. even way back when hurley asked sawyer if he thought she was hot...did sawyer even know who he was refering to. i just came up with this thought and i really dont remember her talking. kinda like dave.

You're just not paying attention. Jack fixed a cut on her hand in Lockdown. Hurley had a conversation with Charlie about Libby (in that I've been terrorized by the Others for 40 days kind of way)
100%
Jesus, yes she is real she is being played by an actor named Cythia Watros. Man people, not everything is trickery. Some things are, but not all things?

But is Cynthia Watros real?

she also tied up sayid after ana shot shannon

In THIS very episode she interacted with several people!!

Sawyer....Moonbeam...Kumbaya...trust falls....?

Unless Libby is Sawyer's "imaginary" friend!! :mad:

My...

Brains...

:eek2:

:biggrin: :biggrin: