I was watching this episode and when the video came on with marvin candle i focused on both his arms. Now we know previously that he is supposed to have a prostetic arm, in this episode it looked as if both his arms were fake

what are your views??

Yeah, I noticed it that about his right arm.

thank god someone else saw that i thought i was going crazy. I'm just trying to work out what could be causing him to lose his limbs could it be the sickness maybe

I saw it too, so either all of us are crazy or he lost both of his arms. Neither arm moved at all in the clips.

I cant say i really noticed his right arm looking fake, but his left arm was i think.

Maybe videos of him in season 4 are gonna consist of just his head and torso, lol.

At least its telling you the order in which these videos are being made.

EDIT: no i dont think either arm moved but his right arm looked a bit of an odd pose? at least if I had a fake arm I dont think I would want my hand in that position (clenched fist?)

his left arm is thought to be prosthetic

http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Marvin_Candle

his left arm is thought to be prosthetic

http://www.lostpedia.com/wiki/Marvin_Candle

With the clenched fist on the right, I didn't think it was fake at all. In the film from the Swan station we saw the right arm move.

I forgot to look at his arms!

With the clenched fist on the right, I didn't think it was fake at all. In the film from the Swan station we saw the right arm move.
thats the mystery...
in one video his arm works,,, in another it is stationary..
Hmmmm.. what happened..
and why does he go by 2 names?

In different videos it's different arms. They're probably just screwing with us. :)