The Dharma Chief
05-24-2007, 11:44 AM
Ethan
Goodwin
2x Unnamed others
Tom
Pryce
Coleen
Picket
Bald Other
Mickhail (He did sorta hold onto the grenade...)
Greta and companion
3-6x Camp attacking others
Total toll: 15-18
Dharma toll (as a result of others): 40+
Lostie Toll(as a result of others): 0 (1 attempted on locke)
Kathleen1
05-24-2007, 12:28 PM
By my count we have
Mr Ecko Killed 2
Anna Killed Goodwin + one =2
Charlie Killed Ethan = 1
Sawyer Killed one last season = 1
Juliet killed Danny this season =1
Sun killed Colleen =1
Mikeal shot Ms. Bea Klugh + 1
Dead from the camp raid = 10
Mikeal shot Greta & Bonnie = 2
Total = 21
Olessi
05-24-2007, 01:06 PM
In terms of people killed by Others, Goodwin killed Nathan and Ethan presumably killed Scott Jackson.
kokobware
05-24-2007, 05:02 PM
How many members now?
Eko
Ana-Lucia
Charlie
Bernard
Sayid
Sawyer
Jin
Sun
Hurley
Juliette
Desmond and Kate have both tried to kill one (Kate, the trailers in Season 2 Finale, and Des tried to kill Mikhail)
Also, Danielle, Michael, Locke and Ben have all killed some one on the island. Not even counting the purge.
Am I forgetting anyone?
Fogey
05-24-2007, 05:06 PM
Well since you neglected to limit the club to Lostee's I propose Mikhail and Ben for membership. They have killed members of their own group :biggrin:
kokobware
05-24-2007, 05:09 PM
Membership accepted! Good call!!! I forget who Ben killed though.
Juliezgroovy
05-24-2007, 11:28 PM
Membership accepted! Good call!!! I forget who Ben killed though.
Ben killed his dad and helped kill the Dharma people. I don't know if they count as Others though. He also shot Locke, after he thought Locke had joined them.
torb28
05-25-2007, 01:35 AM
I suppose in a way Ben killed the girls in TLG since he gave Mikhail the order to shoot them.
Damian254
05-25-2007, 05:52 AM
So Lindeloff said in The Answers show that the Others have 30-40 members in their ranks. So let's just say they have 40 for arguments sake.
So from the tail section crash they take 3 the first night and come back again and take 9 more, according to Anna Lucia. So that puts them up at 52.
Then in this season finale they lose the 10 who got to the camp, bonnie and greta. Also you could say that Juliette, Carl and Alex are defectors. So now they're down to 36.
Other deaths include: Ethan, Goodwin, Pickett, Colleen, Klugh, the two Eko killed on their first night, the person Anna Lucia killed with the list and the guy Sawyer or Kate killed in the season two finale.
So the Others ranks would be somewhere between 17-27 members.
Eight
05-25-2007, 10:02 AM
Ethan
Goodwin
2x Unnamed others
Tom
Pryce
Coleen
Picket
Bald Other
Mickhail (He did sorta hold onto the grenade...)
Greta and companion
3-6x Camp attacking others
Total toll: 15-18
Dharma toll (as a result of others): 40+
Lostie Toll(as a result of others): 0 (1 attempted on locke)
Gretta's companion was Bonnie. Also, I heard the name Ivan for one of the others who stormed the beach. I think he was the bald one.