The dude looks pretty tough, but I am thinking Sayid could take him. It is really a close call though.

Sayid could take anyone.

Sayid's definitely not the strongest of the men in the show, he doesn't really seem to be the best trained either, but I think what separates him from the rest is his experiences.

I wouldn't bet against him. The captain might be some kind of mercenary but he behaves like a jackass, Sayid is nothing if not serious at all times.

I don't know... Captain Hottie, er, Gault is pretty badass.

Sayid should seriously have his own line of Chuck Norris jokes. Hell, Sayid broke that guys neck with his legs--he could easily take on Chuck Norris.

Sayid should seriously have his own line of Chuck Norris jokes. Hell, Sayid broke that guys neck with his legs--he could easily take on Chuck Norris.

Haha so true! Sayid against Gault would be one heck of a fight.

Yeah Sayid is like the Jack Bauer of the island.

I think that Sayid will bring in the paper bag full of Lima bean cans and whack the captain with them.

Sayid should seriously have his own line of Chuck Norris jokes. Hell, Sayid broke that guys neck with his legs--he could easily take on Chuck Norris.

Chuck Norris is an infant compared to Sayid.

Someone get these boys some mud and a couple of loincloths so we can settle this in a way that's mutually satisfying for everyone.

:devil:

Someone get these boys some mud and a couple of loincloths so we can settle this in a way that's mutually satisfying for everyone.

:devil:

:jump1: I'm all for it!

Someone get these boys some mud and a couple of loincloths so we can settle this in a way that's mutually satisfying for everyone.

:devil:
Don't you think that might be more appropriate for Kate and Juliet (except no loincloths)?

Don't you think that might be more appropriate for Kate and Juliet (except no loincloths)?

Nah, didn't they already do the mud wrestling bit? In the end they just both came out still whining, so it wasn't all that fullfilling :D

Someone get these boys some mud and a couple of loincloths so we can settle this in a way that's mutually satisfying for everyone.

:devil:

lol....I'd like to see Sayid's bare legs as he sqeezes the living bejeesus out of Gault.
oh yeah. :biggrin:

<<< Just look at my avatar. :biggrin:

Don't you think that might be more appropriate for Kate and Juliet (except no loincloths)?

For YOU, maybe, but I'd much rather see some of the boys go at it.

Jack vs. Sawyer
Sayid vs. Gault

What's better than hot, angry men covered in mud?

Ah... :hypocrit:
100%
<<< Just look at my avatar. :biggrin:

Hehe, yeah, I love your avy.

Nah, didn't they already do the mud wrestling bit? In the end they just both came out still whining, so it wasn't all that fullfilling :D

True, but that was because they still had the loincloths on:biggrin:

Someone get these boys some mud and a couple of loincloths so we can settle this in a way that's mutually satisfying for everyone.

:devil:

:devil: I love this idea. Now as to who would win my vote goes to Sayid, he could just use his "break dancing" thing as Hurley called it :D

:devil: I love this idea. Now as to who would win my vote goes to Sayid, he could just use his "break dancing" thing as Hurley called it :D

My vote AS OF NOW, would probably go to Sayid because I have yet to see the extent of Gault's skills.

Which is why we need them to get going on what I officially deem "LOST's Ultimate Showdown Tournament" (LUST)...

:clap:

Any chance we can get Jack into this, just for sh*ts and giggles?

I want to see Sayid versus Keamy..is that his name?

I want to see Sayid versus Keamy..is that his name?

Yup. And he's a big dude, but I think Sayid's ankle move could give him the edge.

Yup. And he's a big dude, but I think Sayid's ankle move could give him the edge.

hehe. Locke had the right counter for that move. Sneak up behind Sayid. Smack him on the back of the head. :o

hehe. Locke had the right counter for that move. Sneak up behind Sayid. Smack him on the back of the head. :o

That was the cowardly way to do it. Locke needs to man up! :42fight:

That was the cowardly way to do it. Locke needs to man up!

Hey, some of Locke's best fight scenes feature the cowardly way. Problem with a British guy acting all psychotic? Sucker punch him!

[quote]That was the cowardly way to do it. Locke needs to man up! /QUOTE]

Hey, some of Locke's best fight scenes feature the cowardly way. Problem with a British guy acting all psychotic? Sucker punch him!

Hehehe. Good of you to see the err of Locke's ways, sometimes.

hehe. Hey, when Sayid defeats a polar bear, then we can talk. :grin:

hehe. Hey, when Sayid defeats a polar bear, then we can talk. :grin:

LOL. Well, with all those pretty curls, I'm sure Sayid's got a can of hairspray around, somewhere...

:biggrin:

LOL. Well, with all those pretty curls, I'm sure Sayid's got a can of hairspray around, somewhere...



There you go bringing up the hair thing. Now THAT is unfair fighting.

There you go bringing up the hair thing. Now THAT is unfair fighting.

:harhar1: When a bald man's best weapon against a polar bear is a can of hair product, you better believe his followers are going to hear about it...

When a bald man's best weapon against a polar bear is a can of hair product, you better believe his followers are going to hear about it...

Ehhhh. I got nothing.:ohwell:

This thread started with a debate about two guys fighting. Now its about loinclothes, hairspray and two guys rolling around in mud. Where did it all go wrong?!!!

Sayid could take anyone.
Precisely. His only weakness is getting whacked on the head from behind. If he can see his opponent, he cannot be beat.
100%
I want to see Sayid versus Keamy..is that his name?
You'd have to cuff Sayid's right wrist to his left ankle to make it fair.

This thread started with a debate about two guys fighting. Now its about loinclothes, hairspray and two guys rolling around in mud. Where did it all go wrong?!!!

I entered the fray. It always goes wrong at that point. :devil:
100%
Precisely. His only weakness is getting whacked on the head from behind. If he can see his opponent, he cannot be beat.
100%

You'd have to cuff Sayid's right wrist to his left ankle to make it fair.

Sayid can be beat if you appeal to his heart over his head, apparently. Why else would he turn in Michael?

:rolleyes:

sayid is good, really good, but he's not the undisputed fighting champion on the island. I still say that Sawyer and Jin are right up there with him. Saywer and Sayid were even in their fight after the crash, and Jin beat the crap out of Mikhail just like Sayid did, only without Kate's intervention.

But I have to say, I wasn't really that impressed with the Captain's fighting. It didn't seem anything out of the ordinary. I was more impressed with Jin's, Sawyer's, and even Locke's last season than with the Captains. Besides, it seemed more like his crew members were afraid to fight back. That doesn't gauge toughness of physical abilities, it generates toughness of status.

I think a better question is whether or not Desmond could take the Captain. heh, since he haven't really seen desmond fight other than his seemingly trademark grab you by the collar move. which ironically enough, acidently killed a man! HAH.

Sayid and Jin are heading to Wrestlemania to capture the tag titles i heard!

Why physically grapple with anyone when you can more easily snipe them while concealed in the jungle. A bullet in the brains or heart will bring down any man, except maybe Locke, whose missing those attributes along with a kidney.
That said, Jack/Kate/Sawyer would probably beat all of the above, since they are the eternal stars of the show.

Why physically grapple with anyone when you can more easily snipe them while concealed in the jungle. A bullet in the brains or heart will bring down any man, except maybe Locke, whose missing those attributes along with a kidney.
That said, Jack/Kate/Sawyer would probably beat all of the above, since they are the eternal stars of the show.

Well, considering how many beat-downs Jack has served up, I'd say he's probably a good match to go up against the Captain.

My vote AS OF NOW, would probably go to Sayid because I have yet to see the extent of Gault's skills.

Which is why we need them to get going on what I officially deem "LOST's Ultimate Showdown Tournament" (LUST)...

:clap:

Any chance we can get Jack into this, just for sh*ts and giggles?

I love the name :D

Sayid and Jin are heading to Wrestlemania to capture the tag titles i heard!

:lol: that is too funny, my money is on Sayid and Jin winning the tag team title :D

sayid is good, really good, but he's not the undisputed fighting champion on the island. I still say that Sawyer and Jin are right up there with him. Saywer and Sayid were even in their fight after the crash, and Jin beat the crap out of Mikhail just like Sayid did, only without Kate's intervention.
You've got to be kidding about Sawyer. Even Hurley has beaten him up! Jin is not in Sayid's league. Sayid owned Mikhail from beginning to end, even though Kate came in to finish him off. Jin was thoroughly beat by Mikhail until the very end, when he saw an opportunity to use a strong Taekwondo combo.

I'm surprised this is even a question, now that we've seen Sayid kill a man in about 2 seconds from a sitting position, unarmed, with his hands tied behind his back.

They should stop calling the people on the island "the survivors" and "the Others" and just call everyone "the people Sayid has allowed to live."

I was watching part of Smokin Aces last night and the guy who plays the Captain was in it and doing some major damage in a fight scene. If Sayid was as Rambo tough as people in this thread say, Iraq would not have lost the 1st gulf war so badly.

So I am going with the Captain over Sayid.

They should stop calling the people on the island "the survivors" and "the Others" and just call everyone "the people Sayid has allowed to live."

lmao, I am on board with this.

I'm surprised this is even a question, now that we've seen Sayid kill a man in about 2 seconds from a sitting position, unarmed, with his hands tied behind his back.

And that's still one of my favorite scenes on Lost.

They should stop calling the people on the island "the survivors" and "the Others" and just call everyone "the people Sayid has allowed to live."

:rotflmao2: That's too funny.

The captain looks very hardcore, is better for Sayid dont fight whit him

They should stop calling the people on the island "the survivors" and "the Others" and just call everyone "the people Sayid has allowed to live."

LOL. Good one.

You've got to be kidding about Sawyer. Even Hurley has beaten him up! Jin is not in Sayid's league. Sayid owned Mikhail from beginning to end, even though Kate came in to finish him off. Jin was thoroughly beat by Mikhail until the very end, when he saw an opportunity to use a strong Taekwondo combo.

I'm surprised this is even a question, now that we've seen Sayid kill a man in about 2 seconds from a sitting position, unarmed, with his hands tied behind his back.

They should stop calling the people on the island "the survivors" and "the Others" and just call everyone "the people Sayid has allowed to live."

yeah hurley beat him up when sawyer didn't fight back. sawyer doesnt USUALLY fight back when people hit him, in case you havent noticed, but when he does, he managed to get an AK-47 in a field of about 20 others fighting off three of them at least. He also has by far the highest tolerance for pain out of anyone on the island.

Sides...that fight with hurley was just plain HILARIOUS!! ^.^ (sides when a guy that size tackles you...theres no getting out from under.)

As for the jin sayid mikhail fight....what fight were you watchingt? mikhail kicked sayid clear across the room and bopped him a good three times before sayid had any counter to offer. the fight with jin and mikhail was back and forth even until the end when Jin pulled the kick.

and people who don't know anything about fighting really overestimate how hard that move is to do. you get your legs around someone's neck, you dont even have to FLICK them to break it. people forget that the legs are about 4 times the strength of your arms. charlie could have pulled thatm ove against that other...or boone for that matter. hell...claire could have done it.

I'm surprised this is even a question, now that we've seen Sayid kill a man in about 2 seconds from a sitting position, unarmed, with his hands tied behind his back.

They should stop calling the people on the island "the survivors" and "the Others" and just call everyone "the people Sayid has allowed to live."

This is an amazing statement. :roflmao:I laughed for awhile.

As much of a fan of Sayid and his awesome displays of strength, I'd have to see Gault fight first. Beating up on his crew doesn't count.

This is an amazing statement. :roflmao:I laughed for awhile.

As much of a fan of Sayid and his awesome displays of strength, I'd have to see Gault fight first. Beating up on his crew doesn't count.
Oh, a simple thing, Widmore (a fucking hard old man magnate) will put a pussy as Captain??? I dont think that

and people who don't know anything about fighting really overestimate how hard that move is to do. you get your legs around someone's neck, you dont even have to FLICK them to break it. people forget that the legs are about 4 times the strength of your arms. charlie could have pulled thatm ove against that other...or boone for that matter. hell...claire could have done it.
And yet the guy was a lot deader after walking past Sayid than he was after walking past Jin. :biggrin:

You guys do realize that in real life "sayid" is about 5 foot 5. This guy ain't kickin' anyones booty.

I think Naveen Andrews is pretty badass himself, so, who knows? And I don't think he's THAT short...

You guys do realize that in real life "sayid" is about 5 foot 5. This guy ain't kickin' anyones booty.

He's 5'8" and I've always thought of Naveen as more of a lover than a fighter :biggrin:
However, we're talking about Sayid, not Naveen. Sayid can kick whatever booty the writers want to allow!

Hey- don't be hatin on Hurley. He will get in that VW bus and run over the captain and Sayid.

Yes. Sayid would definitely get hurt, and the Captain would cheat, but Sayid would still win. Why? Because Sayid will cheat better. =)

And yet the guy was a lot deader after walking past Sayid than he was after walking past Jin. :biggrin:

Jin did take out his fair share of others.

Sides, sayid had a vendetta against that guy....he was the one who pulled the gun on him from the side. hehe. You didn't get the sense there when sawyer was about to shoot the guy when Sayid pulled the leg manuver and then looked at Sawyer with the glance of "thanks...but that guy was mine." heh.


heh it should also be noted that that other's name was Jason, the guy who employed the power of "grab kate's right arm, and she becomes as useless as wonderwoman in bondagE" hehehe.

You guys do realize that in real life "sayid" is about 5 foot 5. This guy ain't kickin' anyones booty.

LOL. :) I've witnessed a 70+ year old five-and-a-half foot tall Tai Chi master throw a mid-twenties hulk fifteen feet across a room, with barely a flick of the wrists. It's all about application. Size becomes irrelevant.

Sayid is the Chuck Norris of Lost.

'Sayid never retreats. He just attacks in the opposite direction.'

He could probably take down the captain.

But no man takes down Mr. Eko.

LOL. :) I've witnessed a 70+ year old five-and-a-half foot tall Tai Chi master throw a mid-twenties hulk fifteen feet across a room, with barely a flick of the wrists. It's all about application. Size becomes irrelevant.

Sayid is the Chuck Norris of Lost.

'Sayid never retreats. He just attacks in the opposite direction.'

:rotflmao2: Sayid is the Chuck Norris of Lost

And to quote Yoda "Size matters not" :smile:

You guys do realize that in real life "sayid" is about 5 foot 5. This guy ain't kickin' anyones booty.
You seriously think the tallest guy wins the fight? Jet Li is 5 foot 6.

One of my favorite Chuck Norris jokes applies here:

Everything King Midas touches turns to gold. Everything Sayid touches turns to dead.

But no man takes down Mr. Eko.

I totally agree! Mr. Eko was the toughest and strongest out of all the characters ever on Lost. Too bad he's not around any longer.

Chuck Norris - The only WMD in Iraq

Perhaps the better question is can Chuck Norris kick Sayid's ***?

Yes, Sayid can kick the Captian's ***

Chuck Norris can kick both the Captian & Sayid's *** at the same time

LOL. :) I've witnessed a 70+ year old five-and-a-half foot tall Tai Chi master throw a mid-twenties hulk fifteen feet across a room, with barely a flick of the wrists. It's all about application. Size becomes irrelevant.
Reminds me of the movie Ghost Dog, the scene where it looks like Ghost Dog is going to have to save that little old man from getting his groceries stolen. And then...:eek2:
100%
One of my favorite Chuck Norris jokes applies here:

Everything King Midas touches turns to gold. Everything Sayid touches turns to dead.
:rotflmao2:

But no man takes down Mr. Eko.
I don't know about that. In their fight, Sayid seemed to have the upper hand. Until he was (again) knocked unconscious from behind. To his credit, Eko did drop his stick before tackling him. He obviously could've just whacked him and been done with it.

Despite the Eko's incredible strength, size, and quickness, I still have to give it to Sayid in an even fight. Sayid is just too clever and knowledgeable a fighter. Take his fight with Mikhail. Sayid is in so much pain from his gunshot from Mikhail (and subsequent sewing up of the wound from Mikhail, and subsequent punching of the sewn up wound from Mikhail) that he can't stand upright. So since he has to crouch anyway, he gives him an elbow to the knee joint! That's like the snake in the mailbox... or the spanish inquisition... no one expects the elbow to the knee joint!

That said, there will never be a character as good as Eko.

Someone get these boys some mud and a couple of loincloths so we can settle this in a way that's mutually satisfying for everyone.

:devil:

You should check out Kama Sutra . . . nice wrestling scene, complete with loincloths. And the other dude (Ramon Tikaram) was yummy, too.

You should check out Kama Sutra . . . nice wrestling scene, complete with loincloths. And the other dude (Ramon Tikaram) was yummy, too.

Maybe I can find that scene on You Tube... :thumbsup:

Reminds me of the movie Ghost Dog, the scene where it looks like Ghost Dog is going to have to save that little old man from getting his groceries stolen. And then...:eek2:
100%

:rotflmao2:

I don't know about that. In their fight, Sayid seemed to have the upper hand. Until he was (again) knocked unconscious from behind. To his credit, Eko did drop his stick before tackling him. He obviously could've just whacked him and been done with it.

Despite the Eko's incredible strength, size, and quickness, I still have to give it to Sayid in an even fight. Sayid is just too clever and knowledgeable a fighter. Take his fight with Mikhail. Sayid is in so much pain from his gunshot from Mikhail (and subsequent sewing up of the wound from Mikhail, and subsequent punching of the sewn up wound from Mikhail) that he can't stand upright. So since he has to crouch anyway, he gives him an elbow to the knee joint! That's like the snake in the mailbox... or the spanish inquisition... no one expects the elbow to the knee joint!

That said, there will never be a character as good as Eko.

sayid was also on a mad high adrenaline rush of anger and hate after ana lucia shot shannon. that probably pushed him over the edge on eko. especially since eko didn't even strike sayid.

Whose *** can't Sayid kick?


Only like..Nadia when he was a little boy and she pushed him in the mud...and after that there was no stopping him

OK- I have had enough.

If you all are going to lobby for the "loin cloth" matches then we need equal time for Kate and Juliet to duel it out over Jack. I was thinking the could square off and go toe to toe, maybe in the rain or better yet the mud!

OK- I have had enough.

If you all are going to lobby for the "loin cloth" matches then we need equal time for Kate and Juliet to duel it out over Jack. I was thinking the could square off and go toe to toe, maybe in the rain or better yet the mud!

They already did, didn't they?

OK- I have had enough.

If you all are going to lobby for the "loin cloth" matches then we need equal time for Kate and Juliet to duel it out over Jack. I was thinking the could square off and go toe to toe, maybe in the rain or better yet the mud!

That's fair. And while they're going at it, I'll just sneak off with Jack... :hypocrit:

Sayid is like a calmer version of John Rambo.

Sayid could own anybody!

I think we've had enough of Kate and Juliette. I think we need to see the Alex/Claire mud fight. It may be a bit one-sided, but Claire might surprise us. She did scratch up Danielle's arms pretty good back in season one, and carrying around a baby all the time, both in utero and out, is like a full-time workout regime. If it's an unarmed fight, Alex will probably feel a bit disoriented without being able to rely on her slingshots or blowdarts or whatnot.

I think we've had enough of Kate and Juliette. I think we need to see the Alex/Claire mud fight. It may be a bit one-sided, but Claire might surprise us. She did scratch up Danielle's arms pretty good back in season one, and carrying around a baby all the time, both in utero and out, is like a full-time workout regime. If it's an unarmed fight, Alex will probably feel a bit disoriented without being able to rely on her slingshots or blowdarts or whatnot.


Alex/Claire? No thanks. Now Claire/Juliet- that might work. Battle of the blondes.

I think Sayid would definately win as long as there aren't any weapons involved.

what i'm wondering is if Sayid could kick Kimi's ***... however you spell it... he's got about half a foot on Sayid and his eyes are way dreamier.

i reckon jin would kick the captains ***. i reckon the best closely matched fight we would ever see on lost is sayid versus jin versus mr freindly. what a fight that would be.
100%
Pythagoras99 (http://www.thefuselage.com/Threaded/member.php?u=58712) ive seen alot of avatars and that is still simply the best ive seen.

Pythagoras99 (http://www.thefuselage.com/Threaded/member.php?u=58712) ive seen alot of avatars and that is still simply the best ive seen.

Thanks! :biggrin:

I think Sayid would definately win as long as there aren't any weapons involved.
Maybe. He theoretically has all this military training, but I hope he is a better fighter than a torturer. I don't think he has ever actually extracted info from anyone. Sawyer didn't talk. Ben didn't talk.

can and WILL~!

To inject a little reality here, Sayid is a short guy with no arm reach. Gault would swat him like a fly. No contest.

They gotta do a spin off with Jin, Sayid and all the other good fighters fighting Matrix style. Oh yes.

sayid would beat Gualt so bad his Grandkids would feel it.

You guys are underestimating Captain Hottie. Not that I don't agree that Sayid's a hardcore badass, but still... we don't know what kind of skills Gault really has. Which is why I'm hoping we get to see them throw down.

To inject a little reality here, Sayid is a short guy with no arm reach. Gault would swat him like a fly. No contest.

he did well enough against Mikhail who had longer arms. He used his legs. ^.^

seriously though, Sayid could probably take him. Though he would probably get smacked around a little bit during the course of it.

I think it would be more interesting to see Desmond verses the captain personally, since desmond is probably in better shape than anyone on that island, Jin, Sawyer and Sayid included. (he was definitley in better shape than Jack.) We haven't really seen desmond fight other than his grab you by the collar and angrily scream at you manuver. so it would be nice to see him actually have a fist fight.

I also think Sawyer and Jin could take the captain. it would be interesting to see Jack verses the captain though.

Sayid could kick alot of people's butts!! That's not the only reason I like him though!!
He could definitely take the captain.

To inject a little reality here, Sayid is a short guy with no arm reach. Gault would swat him like a fly. No contest.

If the rules of the fight were The Queensberry Rules, then reach would probably be a factor. As I said above though

I've witnessed a 70+ year old five-and-a-half foot tall Tai Chi master throw a mid-twenties hulk [also trained to a high standard in the same martial art] fifteen feet across a room, with barely a flick of the wrists. It's all about application. Size becomes irrelevant.


The reality is that size matters very little with the right training and application. That's not to say that size can't be an advantage, but you still have to understand how to use that advantage to your benefit. My money's still on Sayid.

The fight I'd prefer to see is Jin vs Sayid. That would be interesting. :)