I've heard a lot of people suggesting that Christian is up to know good. What do you think? And do you believe he speaks for Jacob? I included the "it's not Christian" options as well, as that idea has always been tossed around.

Personally, I think it would be pointless from a storytelling POV to have it be Christian doing all these things, if it wasn't actually Christian. And Christian was always a well-meaning person, who ultimately let his weaknesses get the better of him, but who was nevertheless good-hearted till the end. A transformation from that into a villain seems inconsistent with who he is. So my vote is that Christian is good -- he spoke on Jacob's behalf.
100%
Sorry for the previous incarnation of this thread, if you started to reply there. I took too long to create the poll, so it wouldn't let me add it, and I needed to start a new one.:redface:

My belief is that he is a vessel for opposing forces on the island.
I'm not sure if "Christian" is even there.

I'm making the assumption that we're talking about the Christian we're seeing in the S4 finale. With that assumption I voted that Christian is something else and is anti-Jacob.

Jacob, when Locke 'really' saw him, was in trouble. The cabin moved after that, which is another clue something is going on.