Ben's arm still not explained...

[Miscreant]

There's more to what we saw... All we saw was Desmond punch Ben to a sweet juicy pulp, all in the face no less... Something happens after he emerges from the water that we haven't been shown yet.

I'll bet 3.00 cold hard cash on it.

[CarpeDiem23]

maybe but it could of happened in the rugby tackle, but yeah could be right

[afterthegoldrush]

When Desmond tackles Ben to the floor, he falls on his arm and you can hear a crack.

[Miscreant]

Ben falls on his left arm, his right arm is the one that was injured.

[locke_fan]

Why do fans over analyze everything ???

[Nevermore]

Why do the writers and directors keep making these mistakes?

[locke_fan]

Originally Posted by Nevermore

Why do the writers and directors keep making these mistakes?

We all make mistakes, i'm sure you've made them in your life.
Yes it shouldn't happen in a show such as Lost, they do, they apoligise for them( thinking off Charlotte's age recently)
Considering all the mysteries that happen in the show i'm sure that Ben's broken arm doesn't rank up there.
I think i can work out that ben getting involved in a fight with Desomnd was how it broke it.
I'm sure in the ep when he's calling Jack up he's holding his arm like it's broken.i could be mistaken

[dp2]

Originally Posted by Miscreant

Ben falls on his left arm, his right arm is the one that was injured.

Left.

[b8hoven]

Originally Posted by Miscreant

Ben falls on his left arm, his right arm is the one that was injured.

His left arm was the one that was injured and in the sling.

http://i.iimmgg.com/images/gr/299d04...f2ae6abc12.jpg

[RNugent42]

There ya go..no mistake, go find another scene to nitpick