Still waiting for the beverage cart to roll through
Coach
Are you an Other, or am I?
Additional Info
Kate is an Other
-- She knew that Michael's story about the tents and dried fish was bogus, but she did not speak up
-- The night when Jack, Locke and Sawyer ran into Zeke in the forest, she had sneakily followed them. If she had not done so, Zeke would not have had her to hold up as a "hostage", and he would have gotten his rear end summarily kicked. So Kate followed them for the sole purpose of being captured and used as a pawn. That is why she continuously insists on following them into the woods -- to help deflect and manage any incidents.
-- I believe that they were never in a crash ... that just as Claire was made to believe that she had never gotten on the flight to LA when she was in the medical hatch with Ethan, so everyone has been gathered and (drugged? brainwashed?) into believing that they were on Oceanic 815 and it crashed. Many episodes ago, Jack told Kate that he had become unconscious prior to the plane hitting the ground, but she said that she had remained conscious the whole way -- which would be impossible given that there really was no fall from the sky.
I think the shocker of the season will be when it is revealed that Kate is an other.
I just found it odd that when Michael collapsed before Jack and Kate in the jungle, Jack immediately started looking for Other people and Kate emphatically said "he's alone there is noone else around" ... or something to that effect. Made me a little suspicious.
Wasn't it also VERY funny the way Kate was so sure there was no one else for Jack to go after in the bush when Mike returned. Watch it again, listen to her, she said her lines as if we were supposed to interpret that she definately didn't want Jack going into the bush - and - not in a I'm worried about you being in the bush kind of way - but - in a I don't want you to see something in there kind of way.
-- She knew that Michael's story about the tents and dried fish was bogus, but she did not speak up
She knew that the dirty clothes was bogus, but how could she know about living in tents and the fish from just finding some clothes and glue. She could of made a guess, but she couldn't be sure.
While I agree that Kate's behavior is often erratic and inconsistent, I can't make the connection that she is an Other just yet.
Why would she bring up the findings in the medical hatch with Jack at all? Further, why did she act surprised when finding the costume leftovers in the medical hatch? Wasn't it Claire that found the medical hatch?
As for her following the guys, it could have just simply been a case of curiousity.She has shown in flashbacks that she doesn't use the best judgment.
She knew that the dirty clothes was bogus, but how could she know about living in tents and the fish from just finding some clothes and glue. She could of made a guess, but she couldn't be sure.
How does she know the dirty clothes is bogus? There is no definitive proof that the barefoot people and the group Zeke & Ethan are with are one in the same. In fact, I think they are probably entirely different. Zeke & Ethan went incognito when they knew they were going to encounter Jack and his group...not when they were just walking through the woods thinking they were alone.
I think there are two lots of others. Michael said mainly women. I think they are the experiment that Dharma were doing, hence the kid thing. Also living in tents eating fish, why when there is food delivered by air craft balloon. Don't think Kate is another at all.
While I agree that Kate's behavior is often erratic and inconsistent, I can't make the connection that she is an Other just yet.
Word. That is Kate in a nutshell. Erratic and inconsistent.
I think the reason that Kate insisted to Jack that there was no one else in the jungle is that she did not want him to leave her by herself. Michael was passed out at that point. I think she suspected that there was someone/thing out in the jungle and didn't want to be without her knight in shining armor.
But the way the scene played didn't really convey that very well.
and
and 