Official Claire and Jack are Siblings Thread...

[MinnieVanMommie]

So we know...but they dont..when do you think Jack and Claire will ever have the American doctor Christian conversation???

[Caliban2]

Congratulations to all those who figured this one out.

[benos]

Someone from the lost-media forums did. They even have a youtube trailer of Jack/Claire sibling vid, check it out. But i guess alot of people did too.

[Lunch]

I think this was the first theory that I got right.

[Claudia815]

Originally Posted by Caliban2

Congratulations to all those who figured this one out.

I even won a bet!

I don't think they'll know anytime soon but I'm glad at least we do.

I LOVED the Christian/Claire scenes. John Terry is fantastic.

[DharmaChick]

Yeah, I had really doubted this one, though I accepted it as a possibility.

Maybe she could give Jack some tattoo advice.

[jennylee27]

John Terry probably has had more work on Lost than Emilie De Ravin has. But of course, I am always happy to see them. I believe this plotline was planned from episode 1, and I almost wonder if Jack going to the Others to rescue Ben is a HUGELY drawn out method for the writers to make Jack the person who steals Aaron away from Claire. If Jack is Aaron's uncle, he has the motive to give him a better life. And since Jack is a doctor, giving him an Other patient was a good way to get him integrated over there.

[Save The Humans]

Well, first of all, they need to be at the same place. Then someone's got to tell them. OR, they've both got to see a pix of Christian and exclaim, "DAD!" Something like that.

I'm not holding my breath. . . .

[Betsy]

Can I just say again how much I love John Terry and Christian? He's a wonderful actor and Christian is a good man, despite his flaws. He truly loves his daughter (awwww about the singing to Claire as a baby!)...........I hope Claire realizes that one day.

I wonder if

Spoiler:

she somehow may find out through Sawyer, because spoiler pics indicate that she will be spending some time with him. I know she never found out his name, which makes it tricky, but she's smart. If they get talking and she puts 2 + 2 together..........

I love the idea of Jack/Claire as siblings; I am ready NOW for some great emotional reunion.

---

Originally Posted by jennylee27

John Terry probably has had more work on Lost than Emilie De Ravin has. But of course, I am always happy to see them. I believe this plotline was planned from episode 1, and I almost wonder if Jack going to the Others to rescue Ben is a HUGELY drawn out method for the writers to make Jack the person who steals Aaron away from Claire. If Jack is Aaron's uncle, he has the motive to give him a better life. And since Jack is a doctor, giving him an Other patient was a good way to get him integrated over there.

If that happened, Jack would be a kidnapper and then he could just die as far as I'm concerned. He'd be no different than Ethan - Aaron needs his mother; even if he didn't, how could he possibly have a better life with the Others? Jack is a good guy -he's seen Claire and Aaron, even though he has no knowledge of his relationship with them; how could he even think of doing that? I can even conceive of anykind of storyline where Jack would kidnap his own nephew.

[imaaronsmom]

Originally Posted by Caliban2

Congratulations to all those who figured this one out.

True, true, congradulations to everyone who held on to their beliefs on this one. What a twist! But being she doens't even know his name I can't see how she'll ever find out. It would be so cool for her and Jack to know they are siblings.

What are the chances that two siblings that didn't even know they were related wound up on the same flight that crashes onto an island?