Official Claire and Jack are Siblings Thread...

[Awesoman]

Originally Posted by Caliban2

Congratulations to all those who figured this one out.

I haven't seen this episode yet (graveyard shifts suck), but honestly if you paid attention to the Season 2 DVD bonus disc it's pretty hard not to come to the conclusion these two were related. Throw in the Ana Lucia episode where we see Jack's dad arguing with a blonde-haired woman about seeing his daughter and it's a dead giveaway.

[lostgurl]

I think Ben or Juliet will tell Jack because the Others know everything about everyone on that island it seems. What a better way to get Aaron in their possession - have Jack bring her and the baby there for a 'better life.' Good thing that Jack is just faking!

[EllsBells1960]

Originally Posted by Lunch

I think this was the first theory that I got right.

Me too!!! You could see it coming from a mile away - back in that Ana Lucia flashback.

[hotmutha69]

"Somehow, I've always known"
-Princess Leia, Return of the Jedi

[lostlocke]

Unless she sees a picture of Christian how will they ever find out that they have the same father. I mean Sawyer figured out that he talked to Jack's father in the bar just by talking with Jack, but how would Claire and Jack's conversation go in order for them to find out they are half siblings? I'd like to see that!

[Alien Angie]

Originally Posted by LostLaura

Oh, man.... that is good.... what a theory.
So freakin' creepy.
Would that make Jack

Spoiler:

the new leader of the Others?

I agree with both of these points. They will find out. I think one of the Others will tell Jack.
Claire knew that her father had another family, so it is not a stretch for her to think she might have half-siblings.

I definitely believe, and have always believed, that they were put on the plane for a reason. I agree that it was supposed to land, not crash.

I actually think that Jack will find out off the others, and that will give him the incentive to get back to his group of survivors...quitepossibly the only thing that will have Jack break his promise of being Bens doctor...IMO

Angie
xxxxx

[sickotriz]

Originally Posted by EllsBells1960

Me too!!! You could see it coming from a mile away - back in that Ana Lucia flashback.

I agree. It's cool that they finally confirmed it though. A scene between her and Jack where they find out they're related would be very cool though, much like the scene where Jack learns that Sawyer met his father.

[elfdream]

Ah...vindication. Its a nice feeling. Some of us have suspected this since Season 1.

Now that its out in the open..what are they going to do about it?

[LostLaura]

Originally Posted by elfdream

Ah...vindication. Its a nice feeling. Some of us have suspected this since Season 1.

Now that its out in the open..what are they going to do about it?

What lead you to believe that in S1? The "daddy abandonment crap" that Thomas mentions to Claire?

I just love thinking back to the scene in RBA when Jack is bandaging her hands and asking her questions about the baby. And then he doesn't believe her and she storms off. It's always been a great scene to me. But you can see it almost as a sibling scene. Talking intimately and confidentially, but then ultimately ending in a fight.

[elfdream]

Originally Posted by LostLaura

What lead you to believe that in S1? The "daddy abandonment crap" that Thomas mentions to Claire?

I just love thinking back to the scene in RBA when Jack is bandaging her hands and asking her questions about the baby. And then he doesn't believe her and she storms off. It's always been a great scene to me. But you can see it almost as a sibling scene. Talking intimately and confidentially, but then ultimately ending in a fight.

You know I can't even remember!

There was the thing with the Americanisms in her diary but I guess those were just prop mistakes...but there was a lot more than that. I think it was Jack's flashback when he went to look for his dad in Australia and we got the impression that it was something Christian did on a regular basis and someone somewhere whose name is lost in the mists of time wondered if he had a mistress/second family in OZ and of all the people on the show the person who 'might' be the right age to be a sister to Jack would be Claire...plus the fact that her dad was absent. It just fit.