Official Claire and Jack are Siblings Thread...

[lostgypsy]

Quote:
Originally Posted by producergirl http://forum.thefuselage.com/...s/viewpost.gif
Does anyone remember in the first season where Jack sees his dad and follows him to the cave where there is luggage and the casket he is supposed to be in. That was never addressed - were we to assume his body came out somewhere in the landing? Or... was his dad not ever in the casket because he isn't dead and he is HIM - the "brilliant one" old patchy referred to.... if Jack and Claire's dad masterminded this whole thing and brought them to the island, maybe he's there as well... (we did see him walking around leading Jack, and we do know his body isn't in the casket).....

I've had the creepy notion and have posted before on this that Christian Shepard ( think about that name for a minute) is alive and the * big guy/boss* on the island that we haven't seen yet.

[Claudia815]

Originally Posted by lostgypsy

Quote:
Originally Posted by producergirl http://forum.thefuselage.com/...s/viewpost.gif
Does anyone remember in the first season where Jack sees his dad and follows him to the cave where there is luggage and the casket he is supposed to be in. That was never addressed - were we to assume his body came out somewhere in the landing? Or... was his dad not ever in the casket because he isn't dead and he is HIM - the "brilliant one" old patchy referred to.... if Jack and Claire's dad masterminded this whole thing and brought them to the island, maybe he's there as well... (we did see him walking around leading Jack, and we do know his body isn't in the casket).....

I've had the creepy notion and have posted before on this that Christian Shepard ( think about that name for a minute) is alive and the * big guy/boss* on the island that we haven't seen yet.

<~ Just a lil' though. He's one of my favorite characters and if there's a conspiracy going on, I want him involved. BUT. Am I the only one who has a problem with him being the leader of anything?

[Margalit]

After this was revealed, I kept wondering how exciting it must have been for all those people who do NOT spend hours every day on this board! It might have been fun to be suprised. As for whether J&C will ever know, if the way they come to the realization is through photos ("that's my dada" "that's my dad, too!") it will be a Parent Trap moment!

Beyond that way of knowing, there's not much else left. Claire doesn't know Christian's name. Ana is dead, and so can't say "by the way, when Christian was pounding on that blond's door in Australia..." and I refuse to believe that Christian is alive and well and wandering around the island, no matter what Jack saw.

As ffor the suggestion that Kate i the third in the sibship, after that kiss between her and Jack, all I can say is EEEEWWWWWW.......

[He11FiRe]

Originally Posted by lostgypsy

Quote:
Originally Posted by producergirl http://forum.thefuselage.com/...s/viewpost.gif
Does anyone remember in the first season where Jack sees his dad and follows him to the cave where there is luggage and the casket he is supposed to be in. That was never addressed - were we to assume his body came out somewhere in the landing? Or... was his dad not ever in the casket because he isn't dead and he is HIM - the "brilliant one" old patchy referred to.... if Jack and Claire's dad masterminded this whole thing and brought them to the island, maybe he's there as well... (we did see him walking around leading Jack, and we do know his body isn't in the casket).....

I've had the creepy notion and have posted before on this that Christian Shepard ( think about that name for a minute) is alive and the * big guy/boss* on the island that we haven't seen yet.

I'm really starting to get frustrated. Christian Shephard isn't the leader of ANYTHING. When people on Lost die, they stay dead, TPTB have been quoted as saying so. Christian Shephard died of a heart attack early in the first season, so I don't understand why people keep saying "Christian Shephard is HIM!". Do some research, a lot of these theories have already been debunked.

[silveranswer]

Originally Posted by Save The Humans

Photo. Of. Christian. Among Jack's stuff. Gets seen by Claire. Jack's back by then. "Who is this?" "My father." "But he's MY father!"

It'll happen. Sooner or later.

The Others know everything about our losties. I'm sure they know that Jack and Claire have the same father and I'm sure they'll use it to their advantage. My theory- right now Jack wants off the island, but maybe Ben will tell him about Claire and Aaron to make him want to stay and protect/watch over them. It is awfully hady to have a surgeon around after all. . .

[Mr. Find]

Originally Posted by workingmom

As to how Jack & Claire find out -- I'd kind of like to have Sawyer instrumental in it. I guess Claire probably does not have a picture of Christian given the way they parted in the flashback, but maybe Sawyer will become chatty with Claire and learn that baby Aaron's dad left, just like her dad left her, and that he was a doctor from LA, and how ironic it was that she was headed for LA....and Sawyer's wheels get turning... and we have another great moment like in Exodus where Sawyer can make this known to one of them.

I was just thinking the same thing about how it is too bad Claire doesn't have a picture of Christian to show Sawyer. But that is a good thought you have there: She could start telling Sawyer how her father is a doctor from LA, and so on.

I wonder how Sawyer would handle this situation. Knowing the Lost writers, they will have Jack and Claire getting smiiten with each other, and ready to get romantically involved, at the very same time Sawyer gets this shocking revelation about their common father.

I'm guessing Sawyer will get this revelation in the middle of next season, in the episode right before the winter break, and just before the LOST "ker-thunk" sound and closing credits. Then we can agonize for 12 weeks over how Sawyer will handle this situation. Heck, I am agonizing over it right now!

[jennanne]

Originally Posted by silveranswer

My theory- right now Jack wants off the island, but maybe Ben will tell him about Claire and Aaron to make him want to stay and protect/watch over them.

I'm 100% on board with that.

Originally Posted by workingmom

As to how Jack & Claire find out -- I'd kind of like to have Sawyer instrumental in it. I guess Claire probably does not have a picture of Christian given the way they parted in the flashback, but maybe Sawyer will become chatty with Claire and learn that baby Aaron's dad left, just like her dad left her, and that he was a doctor from LA, and how ironic it was that she was headed for LA....and Sawyer's wheels get turning... and we have another great moment like in Exodus where Sawyer can make this known to one of them.

When I first read this, I just thought oh great, Sawyer definitely needs to get yet another storyline. But, it got me thinking about Christian's Australian backstory and wishing it had played out so that Sawyer was involved. Christian says he went to Australia because he couldn't tell Jack that he was sorry. So he came to see Claire, presumably to apologize to her and try to get a better relationship with at least one of his kids. He finally drinks up the courage to go to see her, gets shut out by Aunt Lindsey, then is left off at the bar where he talks to Sawyer. He was just shut out of his daughter's life, telling Sawyer how some people are supposed to suffer, and then just talks about Jack? Just a simple "neither of my kids will talk to me" would've been good enough - we don't know that Jack wasn't an only child, so it wouldn't have given it all away.

Hmm, guess I've migrated to the group that believes the connection wasn't always planned out.

[jscimeca715]

I know a lot of people think Christian Sheperd is dead and I do too...however, the greatest ending to this season would be Jack and Claire and other Losties locked in a big battle for control of the radio tower or some other landmark and reaching the computer room they throw open the door and all you hear is both of them saying "DAD!" and then the Lost logo flashes and we all put our foot through the tv's.