This will be the shortest Thread Ever!

[care_n_jim]

OK so has anyone on the island EVER told the truth --


How many people have pulled a scam on atleast one other person on the island or off -

I think we should get a list going for those that have been HONEST!

Seriously a list of Lies and a List of Truths --


I cannot think of anyone that has been honest on the island!

[BillToons]

True.. they are ALL scoundrels

[lost_gypsy]

Jack is good.

[care_n_jim]

Originally Posted by lost_gypsy

Jack is good.

But Jack has lied!

[ZoeWashburne]

Originally Posted by care_n_jim

But Jack has lied!

That is true. I think while they have all told lies/scammed and what not, there are differences in intent. Like Hurley tonight scammed Sawyer, but his motivations were actually good - to help Sawyer. Contrast that to someone like Locke, who lied about Boone's injuries and happily sacrificed him up to the island.

It's like how everyone on the island pretty much has murdered someone, but with different intents again. Kate killed in cold blood, as we were reminded tonight. Hurley may have killed twice (the dock and Nikki and Paolo) but both were unintentional.

[shootfire]

Has Jin ever lied? I can't remember a time he ever did.

[Islandprincess]

Billtoons,

Not true. I can't think of anything Rose and Bernard have done which is dishonest...

That's why I miss them so much. They're a "compass" for the show. While the losties seem to be directionless, Bernard and Rose are the paternal/maternal figures on the show who give them direction...they're decent.

[PapaThor]

you are right. r (rose) & b (bernard) were pretty good people.

i vote for r & b being the most honest.

and of course vincent wouldn't lie. unless.............

on a side note, if any of us were on the island,
would be tell the truth to a bunch of strangers
on a plane? hmm? makes you think, right?

[sunshinekitty1]

Aaron and Vincent haven't lied.

Rose let Bernard believe she was cured by the man in Australia, but that lie wasn't meant to deceive.

[care_n_jim]

Rose lied to Bernard - she said that the guy healed her when he told her he couldn't!

I see that someone else pointed this out while I was typing!